You Can’t Be the Dad You Want to Be if You’re Constantly Beating Yourself Up

“I’m failing at this.”

“I lose it, then hate myself.”

“I’m trying so hard, but nothing feels good enough.”

If any of that sounds familiar, you’re in good company. I hear those sentences from dads every week – men who adore their families yet feel stuck in a loop of doubt and self-criticism. One thing I didn’t realise until I began working directly with fathers is that dads are just as likely as mums to experience post-natal depression. About one in ten new fathers meet the criteria, and plenty more hover just under the radar – functioning, but flat, irritable, or numb.

---

The silent weight new parents carry

The arrival of a baby is sold as a highlight reel: tiny toes, first smiles, magical family moments. Real life serves a different edit. There’s sleep deprivation, the thump of responsibility, the sudden loss of spontaneous freedom, money pressures, relationship friction, and the knowledge that a small human now depends on you completely. For some mums and dads that cocktail sparks anxiety; for others a grey fog; for others still, sharp jolts of anger or shame.

Most dads don’t talk about it. We throw an extra item into an already heavy rucksack and keep walking, while the inner critic drips poison:

• “You’re rubbish at this.”

• “Look at the other dads – why can’t you be like them?”

• “Your partner’s exhausted because you aren’t pulling your weight.”

• “Real men don’t feel like crying.”
  

Drip, drip, drip. Each hit erodes confidence, patience and joy. Imagine someone talking to your partner or your child in the same tone you often use on yourself. You’d step in instantly, yet you tolerate that voice in your head day after day. It isn’t harmless background noise. It shapes your mood, your energy and your parenting.

---

Why the way you treat yourself changes everything

Great dads aren’t powered by guilt or brute endurance. They’re powered by self-compassion – the kind that tells the truth, keeps you accountable, and still has your back. When you respond to your own struggles with warmth instead of contempt, several things happen:

• You recover faster after a blow-up.

• You stay calm long enough to connect rather than correct.

• You model healthy self-talk for your kids.

• You create an atmosphere at home where everyone can breathe.
  

Treating yourself harshly doesn’t just hurt you; it steals emotional oxygen from the people you love.

---

Enter Compassion Focused Therapy

British psychologist Professor Paul Gilbert designed Compassion Focused Therapy, or CFT, for people whose inner alarm bells never seem to stop ringing. His question was simple: What changes when we train the mind to meet pain with the same courage and care we’d offer someone we love? CFT weaves evolutionary biology, brain science and attachment theory into a practical toolkit that strengthens your capacity to be kind to yourself.

---

The three emotional systems – a deeper look

CFT describes three core emotional systems. Picture them as separate engines. Each matters, yet they work best when balanced.

1. The threat system
Purpose: Keep you alive by spotting danger.
Dad-world examples: Heart racing when the baby won’t settle, a spike of irritation at your partner’s tone, tension when the boss pings a late-night email.
When it dominates: You snap, withdraw, or spiral into shame. Chronic overuse fuels anxiety, anger and the low mood common in post-natal depression.

2. The drive system
Purpose: Push towards goals, fix problems, secure resources.
Dad-world examples: Overtime to cover the mortgage, repainting the nursery at 1 a.m., ticking off a never-ending to-do list.
When it dominates: Burn-out, restlessness, the belief that you’ll relax “once it’s done” – but it’s never done.

3. The soothing system
Purpose: Help you feel safe, slow down, connect and heal.
Dad-world examples: Rocking the baby while breathing slowly, a quiet chat with a friend, hearing yourself say “You’ve got this” and meaning it.
When it is neglected: No emotional brakes, shallow sleep, joyless days.

Threat and Drive keep the lights on and food in the fridge. Without a strong Soothing engine, though, the other two roar unchecked.

---

Mo – an amalgamation of many dads

Mo was 34 when his second child arrived. With his eldest he’d felt an instant bond; this time, nothing. He sterilised bottles, changed nappies, paced the halls on night feeds – and felt hollow. His inner dialogue swung a sledgehammer:

“What sort of father feels blank?”
“Everyone can see you’re faking it.”
“Your partner deserves better than this.”

Mo’s Threat system blared. His Drive system tried to compensate: more hours at work, strict budgeting, relentless house projects. His Soothing system? Missing in action.

What turned the tide

1. Naming the pattern
   We mapped the three systems on paper. Seeing Threat blazing, Drive over-revving and Soothing idling gave Mo a sigh-of-relief moment: “So I’m not broken – I’m stuck in survival mode.”
   

2. A compassionate image
   Mo pictured his late Nan, famous for warm tea and blunt wisdom. Each time the critic barked, he asked, “What would Nan say?” Her imagined voice – “You’re tired, love, not failing” – cut through the shame spiral.
   

3. Micro-soothing rituals
   Hand-on-heart three-breath reset before entering the nursery. Hot shower as mindfulness cue (“Feel the water, unclench the jaw”). A daily wins log – one sentence a night. The first entry read, “Stayed calm when the bottle leaked everywhere.”
   
   

Four weeks in he felt a flicker of warmth cradling his daughter. Twelve weeks in he belly-laughed during bath time. Same nappies and sleepless nights, different dad showing up.

---

The inner critic’s greatest hits

See if any of these ring a bell:

• Catastrophising: “If I can’t settle the baby I’m obviously useless.”

• Comparisonitis: “All the other dads look like naturals.”

• Should-storms: “I should earn more, weigh less, shout never, smile always.”

• Label slinging: “Lazy, weak, incompetent, selfish.”

• Mind-reading: “She hasn’t texted back; she must think I’m hopeless.”
  

Red-flag cue: absolute language. Always, never, everyone, no-one, stupid, hopeless. The critic loves extremes. Compassion sticks to specifics.

---

An upgraded compassion toolkit

1. The ninety-second threat reset
   Label the feeling (“I’m anxious”). Locate it in your body. Loosen it with a slow exhale longer than the inhale. The threat centre needs about a minute and a half of calm signals to stand down.
   

2. Drive–soothing balance check
   Ask each evening: did I do one thing today purely to rest or connect? Five minutes with a book counts. So does a genuine hug.
   

3. Self-compassion break (adapted from Kristin Neff)
   Mindfulness: “This is hard.”
   Common humanity: “Struggle is part of parenting; I’m not alone.”
   Kindness: Place a hand on your chest. Offer yourself the words you’d give your child.
   

4. The three-P journal prompt – two minutes before bed
   Pain: What stung today?
   Perspective: How would I speak to a friend in the same spot?
   Plan: One small act of care for tomorrow.

5. Compassionate commute
   Use the trip home to down-shift. No emails. Choose music or silence. Ask: what went well, what was hard, what do I need tonight?

6. Partner tag-team
   Agree a code phrase: “Red or green?” If one of you says red, the other covers the baby for ten minutes while the first resets.

7. Wise coach voice-note
   Record a sixty-second message to yourself on a good day – the tone you use with a close friend. Play it back when the critic gets loud.

8. Professional check-in
   If low mood, anger or numbness persists for two weeks, speak to a GP, health visitor or counsellor. Early help prevents a wobble becoming a spiral.
   
   

---

Dads and post-natal depression – signs and myths

Common signals in fathers:

• Irritability or sudden anger spikes

• Withdrawal from family or friends (“Just tired”)

• Excess overtime or reckless spending

• Feeling detached from the baby or partner

• Persistent thoughts of failure or worthlessness
  

Myth: “It’s only hormones; it will pass.”
Reality: It’s a mix of biology, stress, lack of sleep and isolation. Compassionate practices damp the alarm system and build brain pathways that guard against depression, yet sometimes medical or therapeutic support is essential. Seeking help is a responsibility, not a weakness.

---

Being a great dad isn’t about getting it right every time

Your child doesn’t need flawless. They need you – present, learning, willing to repair after mis-steps. Compassion doesn’t make you soft; it makes you steady. It turns mistakes into teachable moments instead of shame grenades. It shows children that feelings aren’t enemies to fear but signals to heed.

Being a great dad isn’t about nailing it first time. It’s about caring enough to keep learning, especially when it’s difficult.

---

Reflective questions

1. What did my inner critic say to me today? How accurate was it, really?

2. Which system – Threat, Drive or Soothing – ran the show this week?

3. How might my self-talk change if I pictured it landing on my child?

4. What tiny act of compassion can I practise in the next hour?
   

---

Final word

Every dad who walks into coaching starts with practical questions – sleep routines, feeding schedules, discipline tricks. Tips matter, yet the breakthrough comes when you change the tone of the voice inside your head. When that voice is kind, calm and courageous, your partner feels it, your children feel it, and you finally feel at home in your own life.

You matter too, Dad. The way you speak to yourself might be the most powerful parenting tool you ever use.

Coaching and Continuing the Conversation

If you’re eager to go deeper, I’d love to support you. I offer one-on-one coaching that focuses on helping dads:

• Develop healthier emotional habits

• Build stronger connections with their children

• Break generational cycles tied to the “man box”

• Foster a caring, stable home where everyone feels safe

If you’re curious, feel free to get in touch and book a discovery call. I’d be honoured to work with you on creating the fatherhood legacy you truly desire.